Mainely Middle

Journal of the Maine Association for Middle Level Education

Back to Table of Contents | MAMLE Homepage

Volume 11, Number 1
2000/2001

 

Author: Anonymous

 

 

Editor's Note: The author of this piece is a middle level teacher. It was his/her request that it be published anonymously. In a cover letter accompanying the article, the author said, "I am proud of who I am today and not ashamed of anything, but many people do not understand the alcoholic."

An Adult Advocate for Every Child...

 

I want you to know a little bit about me so you can understand the impact of what I am going to tell you had on me. I had a change of life style a few years ago when I admitted I was an alcoholic and sought help. That was the beginning of a life of happiness. I was twenty-six years old. I cannot share this with many people because they do not understand, and it makes them uncomfortable. It has actually become the best part about me...

I received a note from a student on my desk. It was during one of those days that goes by in the blink of the eye. I was planning field trips, organizing a class event, and planning two units for my middle schoolers. The anonymous correspondence I received stopped me in my tracks and caused me to reflect on many things at once. I would like to share this poem with you:

Learning

I'm learning &endash; learning to be quiet, not to speak my mind.
I'm learning &endash; learning not to speak out and tell people my opinion.
I'm learning because I have to, to get by...
If I don't say anything they won't say a word
But if I do they will taunt me, tease me.

I'm learning &endash; but do I want to?
I'm learning only because I have to.
I'm learning to let other people run over me to stomp on me
And then hang me out on the line... to dry my tears.
They act like I am only a rug.
I'm learning but I don't want to.
STOP TEACHING ME!

I'm learning &endash; soon I will know and in knowing, use,
and soon I will know no other way to live.
I'm learning...and who is my teacher?
All of you.

from,
Me &endash; but really almost all of us...

I received this in a very carefully folded, triangular package, with the following written on the package:

A cry for help that I'm sending you...

This took me back three years when I was contemplating suicide myself. I did not know who I was or where I fit into life. I was stuck in a self-imposed crisis and I needed help to get out of it. When I felt enough pain and had exhausted all my options, I found it. I reached out and within and received the help, love, and support that was always there for me. Today, this student chose to reach out to me. What an honor! What a responsibility!?!

This happened after my middle level graduate class discussion on advising programs. How serendipitous! Being the go-getter I am, I wanted to start an advisory program immediately and have the staff come up with a harassment policy that would be enforced. Instead, I shared this note with my team and received mixed messages. The guidance counselor and I thought about who it could be and we decided that I would bring it up in a vague way in class and then discuss the plans we had in the making for some harassment awareness for our entire middle school.

Next , I read Howard Johnston's article, "Restoring Purpose to the Guidance Function of the Middle Level School." Johnston discusses the perils that advisory programs experienced in the 70's and 80's and 90's. The problems really came down to a lack of clear vision, programs not consistently implemented, and the adults involved who were not enthusiastic about these programs. He also discussed why they have gone the way of the dinosaur and now are slowly coming back. Our country changed. It has evolved from a post-industrial age to a digital age. Instead of a culture focused on producing products for consumption, the focus of the digital age is on the speed and complexity of connectivity between people and organizations. He noted that we have relied on a top-down mode of thinking as an institutional approach, instead of a bottom-up, or more person to person approach. He notes several events that have had serious effects on our child-rearing practices as a result of this notion. This is what happened:

• Restructured economy which has seen a dramatic increase in the number of two working adult household.

• Mobility of families, often for economic reasons, and breakdown down of extended family support systems where children were raised in the midst of a rather large number of adult kin, all of whom assumed parenting roles.

• Increased age segregation brought about by the institutionalization of care and recreational services.

• A decline in the number of households with school age children, from nearly 67% in 1960 to about 20% in 1990.

• A cultivated aura of fearfulness regarding children &endash; children have been taught to fear adults.

• A lack of immediate purpose of young adolescents. Parents used to say, "I don't know what I would do without Ricky. He helps me in so many ways." Now too many adults say, "I don't know what to do with Ricky, I'm always looking for things he can do to stay out of trouble." In one generation, youth have moved from being a net economic and social resource to a net liability.

So, kids do not really understand adults that much and visa versa. We need to have more authentic contact with kids that will allow them to benefit from the adult contact and visa versa. In my middle level curriculum class, my group developed a continuum of options for what an advising program could look like in a middle school and then developed a definition:

Point 1 on our continuum was an informal check-in with kids with no structure or expectations. This would allow the teacher to be comfortable doing whatever the teacher would like to. The concern was that teachers would do nothing, or, as one of our group members actually experienced, have the kids correct spelling tests. None of us liked this very much. We all believed some sort of accountability and consistency was needed.

Point 3 on our continuum was a very formal and structured advising curriculum. All teachers would follow this boxed curriculum, progress would be measured, and the teachers would be supervised to make sure they are doing it the right way. None of us liked this approach because the teachers probably would not buy into it, and it is not authentic interaction between adults and students. Often in this very formal option the adult(s) do most of the talking and doing and the kids just sit.

Point 2 was our group's favorite. There would be an overriding vision and goals for the program and possibly some shared themes, but the teacher would have some choices and style preferences in how to implement it. The kids and the teacher would evaluate the effectiveness of the program and would have the autonomy to make changes as needed to make the program fit the group of students and adult together.

To add to the strengths of Point 2 from the Johnston article; he suggests that there should be various aspects of the advising program. It should not all be touchy-feely, so all the stakeholders in the learning community can buy into and support it. He suggests an "integrated approach" that ties in school-wide themes, leadership and social skills, interest based clubs, academic skills training; such as skills with standardized tests, organizational skills, and time management, and, finally, a regular home-base check in either as a group or with individual students.

You can see how we came up with our definition:

Advisory Program: A program that will alloweach and every student to regularly connect with an adult that is a sincere and enthusiastic advocate-allowing each and every student the opportunity to feel listened to, voice any problems or concerns, and feel supported and hopeful about their lives and future.

I could have benefited from a program like this. During my middle school years, my mom was dying of emphysema, my dad had just gotten sober and was irritable, my brother left for the army, and I felt alone. If I had had the benefit of regular contact with a caring and supportive adult at school, I might have opened up a bit and began to discuss the pain I felt. That adult might have been able to get me help and prevent the self-destruction I caused in my life. Who knows what is going on in a kid's life? We try to figure it out, but with what degree of accuracy?

I am in a position now to make a difference for a kid that is struggling in some way. I am not going to think it is no big deal. I will do all I can to make a positive climate change in our school and let that child know that I would honor the opportunity to talk with him/her and help in any way I can, or get help for them.

I am thankful that I was in this class and had the opportunity to think about this real school issue before it was a real issue for me. As This We Believe states:

All adults in developmentally responsive middle level schools are advocates for young adolescents. In addition, each student has one adult who knows and cares for that individual and who supports that student's academic and personal development. This designated advocate or advisor must be a model of good character and be knowledgeable about both young adolescent development and middle level education… The ideal school demonstrates a continuity of caring that extends over the student's entire middle level experience so that no student is neglected. (1995, pp. 16 - 17))

I will be an active and enthusiastic contributor to our Harassment Awareness Day, but will also begin to mention an advising program that can fulfill our young adolescents' need for positive, meaningful, and constructive interaction with willing adult role-models.

 

Bibliography

Johnston, H. (2000). Advisory programs to restructured adult- student relationships: Restoring purpose to the guidance function of the middle level school. www.middleweb.com/johnston.html.

National Middle School Association (1995). This we believe: Developmentally responsive middle level schools. Columbus, OH. Author.

 

Back to Top